Close Menu
Buzz NewsBuzz News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • ITR filing FY 2024-25: Why filing Income Tax Return is important even if you have no tax to pay – explained
    • Indian Railways launches new ‘super app’ RailOne: Book IRCTC train tickets, track PNR, food, rail enquiry in one place – what it means for passengers
    • Raymond Realty listing: Shares open below discovered price; brokerages still bullish on long-term prospects
    • PM Modi’s visit to Namibia: Focus likely on diamonds, critical minerals; uranium talks also on agenda
    • Gold price prediction today: Where are gold rates headed on July 1, 2025 and in the near-term?
    • LPG price cut: Commercial cylinders to get cheaper from July 1. But is the benefit coming to your home?
    • Top stocks to buy today: Stock market recommendations for July 1, 2025 – check list
    • 9th yr of GST may see rate rationalisation
    • Domestic gas price rises 5% amid W Asia conflict
    • Cyber risks in financial sector: RBI calls for AI-aware defence and zero-trust approach, warns of systemic threat from vendor lock-ins
    Buzz NewsBuzz News
    Tuesday, July 1
    • Home
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Investment Tips
    • Finance
    • Home Insurance
    • Market News
    • Life Insurance
    Buzz NewsBuzz News
    Home»Health Insurance»States Work to Regulate Health Insurers’ Use of AI to Deny Care
    Health Insurance

    States Work to Regulate Health Insurers’ Use of AI to Deny Care

    BuzzNewsBy BuzzNewsAugust 6, 2024No Comments7 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    States Work to Regulate Health Insurers’ Use of AI to Deny Care
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Telegram WhatsApp Copy Link

    Lawmakers in California are working to join other states regulating health insurers’ use of artificial intelligence tools in coverage decisions.

    At least 40 states have introduced or passed legislation on AI regulation in 2024, with a half-dozen measures related specifically to the health-care industry, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. A common focus of the health-specific bills has been greater oversight on insurers’ use of AI tools to expedite coverage decisions.

    The effort comes as top insurers Humana Inc., Cigna Corp., and UnitedHealth Group Inc. are facing class actions from consumers and their estates for allegedly utilizing AI technology to improperly deny coverage.

    California legislation passed with overwhelming bipartisan support by the Senate and set to go before a state Assembly hearing July 2 would require any health insurer in the state to have a licensed physician supervise the use of AI tools in the utilization review process.

    Bills in New York and Pennsylvania would mandate insurers disclose to providers and individuals when AI is used. At least 11 states have also issued broad guidance on AI standards in health insurance based on a model released in December by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

    Although state efforts to rein in AI are proliferating, they face constraints: it’s hard for states to change AI systems insurers use globally, and states don’t have authority over employer health plans subject to the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, or ERISA.

    But legislators and health law analysts said in interviews that even if the federal government does more to establish holistic standards on how insurers use AI, states still have an integral role as the primary regulators of insurance.

    As many state legislative sessions wrap up for the year, the introduction of legislation is bringing attention to the issue across the country, prompting pushback from insurer groups who argue the bills would lead to unnecessary overregulation of coverage decisions.

    Lawmakers say the proposals can set off a wave of state actions that could force insurance companies to provide more information on their AI tools and how they are used to determine health coverage.

    “These are essentially tools used to make life-changing, altering decisions for people,” said New York Assemblymember Pamela Hunter (D), the sponsor of the legislation there and vice president of the National Council of Insurance Legislators.

    “We can’t wait—consumers need to be protected now,” Hunter said.

    ‘Set a Precedent’

    Health insurance companies have been using AI tools for some time to help in “identifying gaps in evidence-based care to share with providers, improving consumer experience, speeding claims processes, and detecting fraud,” trade association America’s Health Insurance Plans wrote in July 2023 in response to the Biden administration request for information on national priorities for AI.

    But the recent lawsuits against health insurance giants have brought forth allegations that AI tools have overridden doctors’ recommendations on needed care, forcing many patients to pay for treatment on their own or go without care.

    A September 2023 study by KFF found one in five insured adults surveyed experienced a denied claim in the past year. Of those who experienced a denied claim, 55% said they ended up paying more than they expected for treatment or services.

    “When we saw that there were lawsuits and accusations and concerns that insurance companies were algorithmically denying claims without physician oversight, that’s when we started working on this specific bill,” said California state Sen. Josh Becker (D).

    Becker’s bill (SB 1120) passed the state Senate in May in a 37-0 vote with three abstentions. It would apply to both commercial and state-run health plans “to ensure that a denial, a delay, or modification of health-care services based on medical necessity be made by a licensed physician or other health-care provider competent to evaluate the specific clinical issues of the case,” Becker said.

    Becker said he believes his legislation has the potential to “set a precedent and be picked up” by other states.

    In Pennsylvania, where the 2024 legislative session lasts through November, state Rep. Arvind Venkat’s (D) bill (HB 1663) would require state-regulated health plans to provide information on the AI tools they use in their utilization review process to the state Department of Insurance. They would also be required to disclose the use of AI to health-care providers and patients.

    Venkat, an emergency physician, said it’s likely the legislation will get a hearing in the fall in anticipation of a vote in the next legislative session. He noted, though, that his colleagues have questioned whether the legislation should be expanded to address the use of AI across the health-care industry.

    “Should it be really a global regulatory effort related to the health care system as a whole and its use of artificial intelligence? I think that’s a fair point,” Venkat said.

    Hunter said her New York bill (A 9149) will have to be reintroduced next session since the state’s 2024 session ended earlier this month.

    Similar bills were introduced this year in Georgia and Oklahoma, though legislative sessions concluded without floor votes on the legislation.

    In Oklahoma, Republican state Rep. Daniel Pae’s bill would require insurers to publicly disclose the use of AI in utilization reviews, as well as submit the algorithms and training data sets to the Oklahoma Insurance Department.

    “AI doesn’t discriminate based on one’s political affiliation,” Pae said, adding there’s “really strong bipartisan support” for regulating this technology.

    Pae, whose legislation advanced along with other AI bills out of the Oklahoma House Government Modernization and Technology Committee in February, said states are in the beginning stages of addressing how health insurers and others use AI and that the issue is likely to gain more momentum in the next year.

    Patchwork of Rules

    Insurer groups argue the state proposals would go too far in regulating their decision making because the limit of states’ authority could complicate establishing common standards on the issue.

    AHIP, along with the California Association of Health Plans and the Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies, oppose the current version of SB 1120. They wrote in a May 16 letter to Becker that the legislation “would substantially limit who is allowed to conduct utilization reviews by requiring the reviewing provider be within the same or similar specialty as the requesting provider.”

    “If the treating provider disagrees with the reviewing provider, current law already affords a process for the resolution of the dispute through independent medical review,” the groups wrote, adding the provision “is unnecessary and will only add more costs to the health care system.”

    There’s also the issue of regulating AI within a state’s borders.

    While consumer protection and insurance laws have primarily been a state function, AI “doesn’t seem like an issue that should be regulated state by state, because the same stuff is being promulgated nationwide or even globally,” said Michelle Mello, a professor of law and health policy at Stanford University.

    This leads to “a patchwork of different rules” health insurers may have to comply with across states, Mello said.

    There’s some signs of movement at the federal level, as well.

    A bipartisan group of nearly 50 members of Congress sent a letter Tuesday calling on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to clarify the agency’s February guidance that Medicare Advantage plans are required to make prior authorization determinations based on a specific individual’s circumstances, and not soley based on algorithms or software tools.

    “We believe CMS must be more proactive in monitoring plans’ use of AI and algorithm-driven tools,” the lawmakers wrote, adding “plans continue to use AI tools to erroneously deny care and contradict provider assessment findings.”

    care Deny health insurers Regulate States Work
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleFlorida’s Biggest Insurer Says It Needs to Increase Rates by 93 Percent
    Next Article Crypto industry players see light at end of tunnel despite regulatory vacuum. Here’s why
    BuzzNews
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Buying farm land to legitimise undisclosed funds? New Tax tribunal ruling a big blow; here’s how these deals work

    June 30, 2025

    Gold shines bright! Several life insurers want IRDAI to allow gold ETF investments; 30% returns in 12-months

    June 27, 2025

    FY26 life insurance collection: Insurers clock nearly 11% growth in new business premiums in April-May; collections surpass Rs 52,000 crore

    June 9, 2025

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Recent Posts

    ITR filing FY 2024-25: Why filing Income Tax Return is important even if you have no tax to pay – explained

    July 1, 2025

    Indian Railways launches new ‘super app’ RailOne: Book IRCTC train tickets, track PNR, food, rail enquiry in one place – what it means for passengers

    July 1, 2025

    Raymond Realty listing: Shares open below discovered price; brokerages still bullish on long-term prospects

    July 1, 2025

    PM Modi’s visit to Namibia: Focus likely on diamonds, critical minerals; uranium talks also on agenda

    July 1, 2025

    Gold price prediction today: Where are gold rates headed on July 1, 2025 and in the near-term?

    July 1, 2025
    Our Picks

    Bitcoin Remains Above $60,000, Bittensor Becomes Top Gainer

    August 23, 2024

    Prospects For Cryptocurrency Development In South Asia

    August 23, 2024

    Trump announces The DeFiant Ones, a new cryptocurrency platform

    August 23, 2024

    Hackers use McDonald’s Instagram account to steal $700,000 in cryptocurrency scam

    August 22, 2024
    About

    Welcome to BuzzNews, your go-to source for the latest in insurance and finance news. Our mission is to provide you with accurate, timely, and insightful information to help you make informed decisions. From life insurance to personal finance, market news to investment tips, we cover a wide range of topics to keep you updated and knowledgeable.

    Popular Posts

    ITR filing FY 2024-25: Why filing Income Tax Return is important even if you have no tax to pay – explained

    July 1, 2025

    Indian Railways launches new ‘super app’ RailOne: Book IRCTC train tickets, track PNR, food, rail enquiry in one place – what it means for passengers

    July 1, 2025

    Raymond Realty listing: Shares open below discovered price; brokerages still bullish on long-term prospects

    July 1, 2025
    OUR CATEGOIRES
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Finance
    • Health Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Investment Tips
    • Life Insurance
    • Market News
    Copyright © 2024. BuzzNews. All Rights Reserved.
    • Sitemap
    • DMCA
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • About Us

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.